Things Have History
The Bitcoin spot ETF arrives, a decade late

money · 3 min read

The Bitcoin spot ETF arrives, a decade late

On the afternoon of January 10, 2024, Gary Gensler did something he had spent years avoiding. He approved eleven Bitcoin exchange-traded funds — and then, within the hour, released a statement explaining that he had not approved or endorsed Bitcoin. The ink was barely dry when the SEC chairman described the underlying asset as “primarily a speculative, volatile asset that’s also used for illicit activity including ransomware, money laundering, sanction evasion and terrorist financing.” He had been maneuvered into a position he could not escape.

The maneuvering had begun eleven years earlier. On July 1, 2013, Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss filed the first application for a spot Bitcoin ETF — a trust that would hold actual Bitcoin, not futures contracts. Bitcoin was trading near $100. The SEC sat on the application for three years and rejected it in March 2017, citing unregulated market conditions. What followed was a decade of the same pattern: applications filed, applications rejected, applicants refiling under different structures, applications rejected again.

The paradox that finally undid the SEC was of its own construction. Beginning in 2021, the agency had approved ETFs holding Bitcoin futures contracts — financial derivatives settled in cash rather than actual coins. It continued to block spot ETFs, arguing that Bitcoin’s spot markets were too vulnerable to manipulation. Grayscale Investments argued this distinction was incoherent: a futures ETF and a spot ETF track the same underlying asset through different mechanisms; if one passed muster, so should the other. On August 29, 2023, the United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit agreed unanimously. The SEC had failed to “adequately explain why it approved the listing of two bitcoin futures ETPs but not Grayscale’s proposed bitcoin ETP.” Unlike treatment of like products without explanation is arbitrary and capricious. The court vacated the denial.

What followed was the administrative equivalent of an orderly retreat. On January 10, 2024, the SEC approved all eleven pending spot Bitcoin ETF applications at once, from BlackRock, Fidelity, Grayscale, ARK 21Shares, Bitwise, WisdomTree, VanEck, Invesco Galaxy, Valkyrie, Hashdex, and Franklin. A Bitwise survey conducted before the decision had found that 88 percent of financial advisers were waiting for precisely this approval before recommending Bitcoin to clients — not for lack of conviction, but because an ETF sat inside the custody and compliance infrastructure their clients already used. On January 11, the first trading day, the eleven funds moved $4.5 billion in volume. Grayscale led with $1.9 billion; BlackRock and Fidelity followed.

The ETF structure solved a problem that had nothing to do with Bitcoin’s technology. Retirement accounts, brokerage platforms, and adviser relationships are built around regulated wrappers. Without an ETF, recommending Bitcoin meant recommending something that existed outside every custody framework a typical client used. The approval brought Bitcoin inside those frameworks without changing anything about Bitcoin itself.

Satoshi Nakamoto’s 2008 whitepaper described a peer-to-peer electronic cash system requiring no trusted third party. By January 2024, that system could be purchased inside a Fidelity 401(k), on NASDAQ.

Sources

Spot a mistake?

Wrong date, broken citation, a fact that doesn't hold? Tell us. It lands in an inbox a human reads and the post can be pulled or corrected.